John 11:39, He Stinketh
Posted on Sunday, January 20, 2013 in Bible Commentary | 4 comments
Jesus said, Take ye away the stone. Martha, the sister of him that was dead, saith unto him, Lord, by this time he stinketh: for he hath been dead four days.
//I laughed at Rob Bell’s humorous discussion of this verse in Velvet Elvis, but in truth, the phrase “he stinketh” struck me as memorable long ago, too.
Jesus’ beloved friend Lazarus has died, and four days later, Jesus shows up at the tomb. But Martha, the sister of Lazarus, has lost hope. Lazarus is so far gone that he stinketh. Nevertheless, Jesus raises him back to life.
I confess, I don’t read this story literally … I find too many clues that it was meant to be read rather as a parable of new life. Think of the prodigal son, of whom it was said, “This my son was dead, and is alive again.” The poor man had squandered all that he owned, and wound up with the smelly job of feeding swine. Likewise, Lazarus has fallen so deep into sin that he stinketh.
Ever feel that way yourself? It can be a harsh awakening to discover we’re so far gone that we stinketh. Nevertheless, new life is still possible, and Jesus can help.
4 Comments
Leave a Reply Cancel reply
The Way It Happened
|
|
| Revelation: A love story gone awry. | The Gospel: A love story set aright. |
What really happened 2,000 years ago? How did a persecuted minority of end-time believers known as Christians, with their dreams of Armageddon and a conquering Messiah named Jesus, evolve into the largest religion in the world? Author Lee Harmon explores the period in which the New Testament was written in his books about John's Gospel and Revelation.
(Bloggers: you may be eligible for a free review copy! Just contact us.)
The God Show
Enjoy The Dubious Disciple?
Book Reviews
- Book review: John’s Gospel, The Way It Happened
- Book review: Natural God, Deism in the Age of Intelligent Design
- Book review: Daughter of the King
- Book review: Muhammed, A Prophet For Our Time
- Book review: Sunday Morning Stickup
- Book review: God or Godless?
- Book review: Prodigal Christianity
- Book review: Jesus Wants To Save Christians
- Book review: The Essence of Religions
- Book review: Navigating Revelation
- Book review: Chasing an Elusive God
- Book review: Paradise Earth: Day Zero
- Book review: Exposing Myths About Christianity
- Book review: The Holy Family
- Book review: The Almond Tree
- Book review: Exploring Faith and Reason
- Book review: On God’s Side
- Book review: The Myth of Persecution
- Book review: Romance Eternelle
- Book review: An Uncertain Age
- Book review: How To Be An Agnostic
- Book review: Let The Bible Be Itself
- Book review: Faitheist
- Book review: John’s Gospel: The Way It Happened
- Book review: Walking Toward Morning
- Book review: Crossing the Street
- Book review: The World That Shaped the New Testament
- Book review: Revelation: The Way It Happened
- Book review: Deconstructing Lucifer
- Book review: A Faith of Our Own
Bible Commentaries
- Acts 11:36, I am a Christian
- Mark 3:29, Blasphemy Against the Holy Spirit
- Job 19:23-24, Carved With Iron and Lead
- Daniel 1:1, When Was Daniel Written
- Judges 4:21, How Did Sisera Die?
- Genesis 1:27, Is God Our Heavenly Mommy?
- Exodus 21:22-23, Is Abortion a Sin? part II of II
- Psalm 139:13, Is Abortion a Sin? part I of II
- Psalm 8:4, Leave Me Alone, God!
- Leviticus 25:13, The Jubilee Year
- Genesis 30:13, The Twelve Tribes of Israel, part II of II
- Judges 5:17, The Twelve Tribes of Israel, part I of II
- Leviticus 22:11, Slavery in Israel
- Daniel 12:7, Scattering the Jews
- John 13:5, Washing Our Feet
- Numbers 12:10, Black and White
- 2 Kings 22:8, Where did the book of Deuteronomy come from?
- Psalm 105:27, The Seven Plagues of Egypt
- Genesis 26:7, Sarah the Sex Slave, part III of III
- Genesis 20:1-2, Sarah the Sex Slave, part II of III
- Genesis 12:11-13, Sarah the Sex Slave, Part I of III
- Isaiah 58:10, The Cure For Depression
- 1 Kings 3:25, Solomon’s Metaphor (Cut the Baby In Two!)
- Psalm 104, The Great Hymn to the Aten
- 1 Samuel 3:4, Is Suicide a Sin?
- John 19:34, Jesus’ Side Is Pierced
- 1 Kings 6:1-2, Solomon’s Palace and Temple
- Exodus 12:37-38, The Conquest of Canaan (part III of III)
- Judges 1:8, The Conquest of Canaan (part II of III)
- Exodus 1:11, The Conquest of Canaan (part I of III)
Archives By Month
Archives By Category
About Me
Hello! I'm an author, historical Jesus scholar, book reviewer, and liberal Christian, which means I appreciate and attempt to exercise the humanitarian teachings of Jesus without getting hung up on supernatural or religious beliefs.
The Bible is a magnificent book that has inspired and spiritually fed generations for thousands of years, and each new century seems to bring a deeper understanding of life’s purpose. This is true of not only Christianity; through the years, our age-old religions have slowly transformed from superstitious rituals into humanitarian philosophies. In short, we are growing up, and I am thrilled to be riding the wave.
I avidly read all thought-provoking religion titles. New authors: I'd love to read and review your book!
Contact me here. My Favorite Feeds
- James' Thoughts and Musings
Ambrose's Nixon: The Triumph of a Politician 7: I have two items for my blog post today on Stephen Ambrose's Nixon: The Triumph of a Politician, 196... - Maphead's Book Blog
Infection: The Uninvited Universe by Gerald Callahan: While winter has long been considered the cold and flu season, so far this spring, reading-wise anyw... - The Bible and Culture
The Rankin File— Tooth and Nail: While I was in Edinburgh, there was a tour on offer, where one would apparently ride around and gawk... - The Religious Left
Our Saturday Moment: By Garrett FitzGerald Originally posted on Holy Saturday, 2012A few years ago, I was privileged to... - Threads From Henry's Web
The Federal Government Could Save Some Money: … by not doing this. Maybe some of those states’ rights advocates could apply some state... - Vridar
Science and Religion: Four Fundamental Differences: Religion has not gone away since the end of the Europe’s religious wars and the ensuing Age of...








While I don’t take the passage literally either, there is no evidence that Lazarus’ life was in such bad shape from being a bad guy that he “stinketh” (stunketh?)with sin, although that could be true. In order for your interpretation to work properly, you have to create that stinking sinner idea as an assumption.
Otherwise, the basic lesson seems good: you can’t possibly be too far gone for Christian faith to no longer be effective.
Hi BGM! Perhaps we must first figure out who Lazarus is. Precious little is provided in scripture, so speculation runs amok. I take a stab at the question in my own book about John’s Gospel.
Just found your blog, Lee, really enjoying it!
As to Lazarus,there are hints from other sources that Lazarus (via his family) was wealthy. He may have been the “rich young man” referred to in the synoptics. Luke uniquely adds the parable of poor Lazarus and an unnamed rich man; in the afterlife their roles are interestingly reversed — Lazarus has wealth/the good life in heaven as a reward.
If The Secret Gospel of Mark is legitimate, as I believe it is (and not a modern forgery), it indicates that Lazarus is the young man in the white linen being taught the mysteries of the Kingdom of God by Jesus in the garden just before Jesus is arrested. These odd verses 14:51-52 in Mark seem to be out of place or come out of nowhere. It seems Lazarus here is symbolic of one who is initiated into the mysteries by first “dying” and then experiencing rebirth, perhaps through baptism (where baptism washes away our past/former life of sin/death). If this connection is correct, then it is also young Lazarus (reborn) who is the young man in white in the empty tomb (Mark 16:5) who announces to the women “He is risen! He is not here.”
Lazarus then for me represents the person (wealthy or otherwise) — even so far gone “he stinketh” — who is the ideal disciple (perhaps even the beloved disciple?), who has given up all to become Jesus’ disciple and undergone the internal transformation of death and rebirth, i.e., rising above or transcending death.
Hi Wendy! Sooo much speculation on who the mysterious Lazarus was! It’s a great topic. I weigh in on the topic with my own book on John’s Gospel, and I find it fun to speculate about the connection between Lazarus and the young man in Mark. Great minds, eh??
Thanks for contributing!